oppn parties SC Directs RBI To Frame Rules For Locker Management

News Snippets

  • Supreme Court stays Karnataka HC order blocking operations of Kannada news channel Power TV. Says right to free speech must be "zealously protected" by courts
  • Opposition slams Centre for Samvidhan Hatya Diwas, says the Constitution is being murdered on daily basis under the present BJP government
  • Centre notifies June 25 as 'Samvidhan Hatya Diwas'. This was the date on which Indira Gandhi imposed the Emergency in 1975
  • Bengal moves SC against state governor for keeping 8 bills pending
  • Mamata Banerjee meets Uddhav Thackeray in Mumbai, says 'khela on' and promises to campaign for his party in the Maharashtra assembly elections
  • Stars and eminent persons from across the globe attend the wedding of Anant Ambani with Radhika Merchant at the Jio World Convention Centre in Mumbai
  • Controversial IAS trainee Puja Khedkar faces dismissal from service if her quato and disability claims are found false
  • SC says stay on bail should be in rare cases like terrorism or where order is perverse otherwise personal liberty and Article 21 will go for a toss
  • Supreme Court says judicial review of arrests by ED is necessary to check improper exrecise of power to arrest
  • Supreme Court grants interim bail to Arvind Kejriwal in the money laundering case in Delhi liquor policy case but he will remain in jail as he is under CBI detention in the corruption case in the same scam
  • Retail inflation rises to 5.1% in June, the highest in 4 months
  • Government to avoid merger of BSNL-MTNL. Instead, MTNL's operations will be shifted to BSNL to give the latter an all-India presence
  • Women's U-19 Asia Cup: India to clash with Pakistan on July 19
  • Paris Olympics badminton draws: P V Sindhu in easy group but gets a tough draw later while H S Prannoy and Lakshya Sen might clash in pre-quarter finals
  • After two consecutive wins, India look to seal series when they meet Zimbabwe in the 4th T20 today
BJP and allies win all 9 seats they contested in the Maharashtra Legislative Council poll
oppn parties
SC Directs RBI To Frame Rules For Locker Management

By A Special Correspondent
First publised on 2021-02-20 06:04:44

In a landmark order that will bring relief to thousands of bank customers who face, or have faced, problems in maintaining safe deposit lockers with banks, the Supreme Court today ruled that since banks are custodians of public property, there liability does not cease by claiming that they do not know the contents of the locker and that no bank can break open a customer's locker without informing him or her.

The case before the bench was about a customer of United Bank of India's Kolkata branch whose locker was broken open by the bank officials on the plea that he had not paid rent for a year. The locker was allotted to someone else. When the customer proved he had paid the rent, the bank admitted its mistake. But when the customer wanted his contents back, the bank could only return 2 pieces of jewelry instead of the 7 the customer claimed were kept inside the locker.

The customer chose to move the district consumer forum and was granted a compensation of Rs 3lakh as cost of jewelry and Rs 50000 for mental harassment. But the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission reduced the amount to just Rs 30000. Aggrieved by that, the customer approached the Supreme Court, leading to the above order.

The Supreme Court said that "Banks are under the mistaken impression that not having knowledge of the contents of the locker exempts them from (the) liability for failing to secure the lockers in themselves as well." It also said that banks "cannot impose unilateral and unfair terms on consumers."

It awarded the customer Rs 5 lakh as compensation and Rs 1 lakh as legal costs. It directed the bank to recover Rs 5 lakh from the erring officials if they were still in service. Observing that the "present state of regulations on locker management is inadequate and muddled" the court also laid down a 15-point guideline for locker operations and asked the RBI to frame new rules for the same within 6 months. The court directed that these rules will have to be followed by all banks in India.

But it has to be considered that this case was 25-years old. Since then, there has been some transparency in locker management and banks usually do not break open a locker before giving notice to customers if rents remain unpaid. Even if they have to break open any locker, it is done in the presence of two bank officials and one or two independent witnesses, usually any other customers of the bank. A complete inventory of the contents found inside the locker is made and signed by those present. Still, different banks follow different rules. Hence, the Supreme Court has done the right thing to direct the RBI to frame comprehensive rules that will be followed by all banks. 

pic courtesy: indiamart.com