oppn parties 'Retrospective Tax' Does Not Pass Muster, Vodafone Not Required To Pay The Demand Of Rs 20000 Crore

News Snippets

  • T20 WC: USA enter Super Eights as their last match against Ireland gets washed out. They were ahead of Pakistan in the points tally. Pakistan were eliminated
  • T20 WC: USA enter Super Eights as their last match against Ireland gets washed out. They were ahead of Pakistan in the points tally. Pakistan were eliminated
  • BJD leader and former Odisha CM Naveen Patnaik said that the criticism of his aide V K Pandian is "regrettable"
  • As more than 20 BJP ministers lost in the recent elections, the new Union cabinet will have many new faces from the party
  • Congress Working committee asks Rahul Gandhi to take up the position of Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha. Gandhi says he will consider the request
  • RBI governor Shaktikanta Das said that gold was shifted to India as the quantum of RBI gold abroad had increased due to recent purchases
  • Delhi HC rules that submitting photographic evidence of adultery will not be enough, they will have to be proved as authentic in the age of deepfakes
  • A four-member panel will review NEET-UG results of 1563 candidates to check if they were given extra marks for exam time loss
  • Mamata Banerjee says her party will not join Modi's oath-taking ceremony. Also says INDIA bloc might stake claim to form government later
  • K C Tyagi of the JD(U) dropped a bombshell when he said that Nitish Kumar was offered the post of prime minister for switching sides. Opposition leaders rubbished the claim
  • This May was India's hottest month in 36 years says IMD
  • T20 WC: India take on Pakistan today. Telecast to begin at 8pm IST
  • T20 WC: Afghanistan stun New Zealand and Bangladesh win against Sri Lanka
  • T20 World Cup: Australia beat England by 36 runs. This spoils England's chances of making the playoffs as they have lost both their matches till now
  • Heat wave continues in the country as monsoon moves slow
G7 commits to promote India-Europe corridor
oppn parties
'Retrospective Tax' Does Not Pass Muster, Vodafone Not Required To Pay The Demand Of Rs 20000 Crore

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2020-09-25 20:45:15

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.

The retrospective tax got a huge kick on the backside today when an international court in The Hague ruled that it violated the investment treaty between India and Netherlands in the case between the Indian government and Vodafone. Consequently, India lost the case and Vodafone is not required to pay nearly Rs 20000 crore that was levied as interest and penalties with retrospective effect when the Income Tax department had ruled that the company had to pay these amounts on its acquisition of the Indian assets of Hutchison Whampoa (Hutch) in 2007.

Vodafone had disputed that and had even won the case in the Supreme Court. But the then UPA II government had changed the rules and made it applicable from retrospective effect. India Inc. had protested this 'retrospective tax'. It amounted to changing the goal posts after the match had started and it was an unethical thing to do. If Vodafone had known beforehand that its acquisition of Hutch would entail an additional payment of Rs 20000 crore as interest and penalties, it would have negotiated the deal differently.

Fairness and transparency in taxation demands that even if the government stands to lose substantial revenue, rules must not be changed with retrospective effect. It makes a country a hostile investment destination if the government keeps changing tax rules to fleece investors, especially when the rule was not there when they first came in. The 'retrospective tax' was widely criticized then but the then government stuck to its guns. Perhaps losing the arbitration case now will drill some sense in the bureaucracy and they will not come up with such fancy stuff in future.

In India wants to be the preferred destination for companies looking to move out of China post the pandemic, it has to spell out all its policies in black and white with a caveat that rules will not change with retrospective effect to harm done deals. The difficulty overseas companies face in doing business in India is one of the biggest reasons that despite the hype around 'Make in India' the country is not seeing even 5 percent of what was invested in China. Although the NDA government is trying, it is not enough. We have to junk outdated thinking and the propensity to change rules at the drop of a hat. On the ease of doing business, we are nowhere even near to the countries competing with us to lure the companies that are expected to look for investment destinations if and when they move out of China.