oppn parties Mediclaim Cannot Be Denied for Genetic Disorders, Rules Delhi HC

News Snippets

  • 2nd ODI: Rohit Sharma roars back to form with a scintillating ton as India beat England by 4 wickets in a high scoring match in Cuttack
  • Supreme Court will appoint an observer for the mayoral poll in Chandigarh
  • Government makes it compulsory for plastic carry bag makers to put a QR or barcode with their details on such bags
  • GBS outbreak in Pune leaves 73 ill with 14 on ventilator. GBS is a rare but treatable autoimmune disease
  • Madhya Pradesh government banned sale and consumption of liquor at 19 religious sites including Ujjain and Chitrakoot
  • Odisha emerges at the top in the fiscal health report of states while Haryana is at the bottom
  • JSW Steel net profit takes a massive hit of 70% in Q3
  • Tatas buy 60% stake in Pegatron, the contractor making iPhone's in India
  • Stocks return to negative zone - Sensex sheds 329 points to 76190 and Nifty loses 113 points to 23092
  • Bumrah, Jadeja and Yashasvi Jaiswal make the ICC Test team of the year even as no Indian found a place in the ODI squad
  • India take on England in the second T20 today at Chennai. They lead the 5-match series 1-0
  • Ravindra Jadeja excels in Ranji Trophy, takes 12 wickets in the match as Saurashtra beat Delhi by 10 wickets. All other Team India stars disappoint in the national tournament
  • Madhya Pradesh HC says collectors must not apply NSA "under political pressure and without application of mind"
  • Oxfam charged by CBI over violation of FCRA
  • Indian students in the US have started quitting part-time jobs (which are not legally allowed as per visa rules) over fears of deportation
Manipur Chief Minister Biren Singh resigns after meeting Home Minister Amit Shah and BJP chief J P Nadda /////// President's Rule likely in Manipur
oppn parties
Mediclaim Cannot Be Denied for Genetic Disorders, Rules Delhi HC

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2018-03-02 13:26:57

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.
The Delhi High Court has ordered that insurance companies cannot deny mediclaim just by saying that the disease for which coverage is demanded is due to “genetic disorder.” Saying that the term “genetic disorder” is all-encompassing and not clearly defined, the court ruled that any broad exclusion of genetic disorders from either insurance contracts or claims is illegal and unconstitutional. It also took the insurance regulator IRDA to task by saying that it “ought to have supervised the manner in which the term genetic disorders are being misused by insurance companies to reject genuine claims. Obviously the IRDA turned a blind eye to the functioning of insurance companies.”

The case under consideration was that of one Jay Prakash Tayal who had a mediclaim policy with United India Assurance Company, a state insurer. Tayal was diagnosed with Hypertrophic Obstructive Cardiomyopathy , a condition that thickens portions of the heart reducing its capacity to pump blood. The insurer refused to entertain the claim by saying that it was a genetic disorder and was hence excluded under the general exclusions clause. Tayal approached the trial court in 2016 which ruled in his favour. Terming exclusion of genetic disorders “arbitrary, discriminatory and unfair”, Judge Kamini Lau had said in her order that "no person can be discriminated or deprived of state protection in case of an ailment, be it genetic or acquired. The courts of law are required to interpret the provisions of the private contracts in the light of these constitutional obligations.”

Aggrieved with this order, United Insurance appealed to the Delhi HC which has again ruled in Tayal’s favour. It has to be recognized that in the absence of proper investigations, terming any disease to have arisen due to genetic disorder is blatantly wrong. It is both medically and legally unfair to attribute something to any other thing without irrefutable proof. Apart from some proven conditions, even the medical community is divided over what other conditions can irrefutably be said to have happened due to genetic disorder. Hence, insurance companies cannot shirk their responsibility by hiding behind this loophole.