oppn parties Malls And Parking Charges

News Snippets

  • EMI's set to rise after the RBI hikes key policy rate
  • Calcutta HC says that the right to privacy does not end with the death of a person
  • Supreme Court says that a delayed order of preventive detention makes it invalid
  • Shashi Tharoor posts an erronous map of India in his manifesto, rectifies the error after criticism
  • Sonia Gandhi to take a call on who will be Rajasthan chief minister
  • Mallikarujun Kharge to be the new candidate to oppose Shashi Tharoor in the Congress presidential elections
  • RBI says that the September inflation rate may be higher than 7%
  • RBI hikes key rates by 50bps, downwardly revises FY23 growth rate to 7% from 7.2% earlier
  • Stocks recover well on Friday: Sensex gains 1016 points to0 57426 and Nifty 276 points to 17094
  • Mirabai Chanu wins gold easily at the National Games
  • In a first, the Supreme Court recognizes marital rape, although for the limited purpose of allowing married women the right of abortion up to 24 weeks if they conceived as a result of forced sex by their husbands
  • Air India cuts discounts on base fare to students and senior citizens from 50% to 25%
  • Mallikarjun Kharge and Digvijay Singh are being touted as frontrunners to take on Shashi Tharoor in the elections for the post of Congress president
  • Sonia Gandhi will decide who will be Rajasthan CM if she feels there is a need to change guard after the near-rebellion by MLAs in the state
  • Ashok Gehlot bowed out of the race for being Congress president after meeting Sonia Gandhi
RBI hikes key rates by 50bps, stocks jump and recover 50% of the losses incurred in the last few session
oppn parties
Malls And Parking Charges

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2022-01-25 08:20:38

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.

The Kerala High court has ad that prima facie, malls cannot charge parking fees from customers who visit the malls. It has cited building rules which mandate that given the size of the building, parking has to be provided for a certain numbers of cars to ease the load on surrounding streets and roads. It has therefore questioned the local municipality in Ernakulam whether it had issued a licence to the Lulu International Mall for collecting parking fees from patrons.

It is irksome to pay parking fees at malls for the simple reason that being a customer one is going to provide business to the shops and other outlets in the mall and should ideally not be charged for parking one's vehicle in the designated parking space. But in reality, parking spaces are costly and there is a trade-off between providing parking spaces or having more outlets. Hence, the mall owning company forgoes revenue when it provides parking space. A parking area in a private commercial complex cannot be deemed as a public space.

Then, while building rules do mandate provision of parking space, nowhere is it specified that such parking space will be free. Apartments either include the cost of parking spaces in the cost of flat or even charge for it separately. If apartments and societies can sell parking spaces, ideally, malls and multiplexes cannot be legally stopped from levying parking charges. Further, municipal corporations or any other licensing authority do not have jurisdiction over privately-owned parking spaces. They can only award licenses for collection of parking fees on land owned by them, or on roads and street under their jurisdiction.

This problem is running since 2019 when the Pune Municipal Corporation made parking free for all at all malls and multiplexes citing an order by Andhra Pradesh HC to this effect. The Gujarat HC also passed a similar order stopping malls from collecting parking fees in 2019. In 2020 malls in Vishakhapatnam were asked to stop collecting parking fees. The malls then converted it to maintenance charges, in line with restaurants that started levying establishment charges when asked to sell mineral water and aerated drinks at MRP. Prima facie, this is really an ethics issue and needs to be addressed by mall owner and outlets.

In some places, the larger outlets usually ask patrons if they require parking coupons for vehicles parked in the mall if one purchases goods from them. That really is the best solution. Outlets that benefit from the custom of patrons should ideally subsidize parking charges. But it will not be feasible in case of people going to watch movies in multiplexes in malls. For they will spend more than three hours and will be charged a minimum of Rs 60 for parking their cars. Multiplexes would not be able to reimburse the amount to them on their ticket prices as that would lead to loss of huge revenue. Mall owners and tenants must sit together and work out a formula that does not deprive revenue for the malls and at the same time does not antagonize patrons. 

Feedback: We would love to hear your opinion about this article and India Commentary. Please email your opinions at editorialindiacommentary@gmail.com