oppn parties Franco Mulakkal Rape Verdict: Shocking

News Snippets

  • Delhi Additional district judge Nikhil Chopra says there is no legal right for people seeking to worship deity inside Qutab Minar, says it survived 800 years without worship so "let it survive like that"
  • Punjab chief minister Bhagwant Mann sacks state health minister Vijay Singla over corruption charges. Singla was later arrested by the ACB
  • Protestors burn the house of Andhra minister P Viswaroop and MLA Satish Kumar over renaming of Konaseema district as B R Amberdkar Konaseema
  • Gyanvapi: Varanasi district judge decides to first hear the 'maintainability' plea filed by mosque management
  • Delhivery and Venus Pipes shares list at premium of 10% and 8.7% respectively even when market sentiment was down
  • In a bid to cool edible oil prices, Centre allows duty-free imports of 20 lakh tonnes each of crude sunflower oil and crude palm oil per annum this year and next
  • Centre caps sugar exports to ensure availability of stocks in the domestic markets to cool prices
  • Stock markets get the jitters as RBI signals rate hike and government moves in to control inflation: Sensex tumbles by 236 points to 54052 and Nifty goes down by 89 points to 16125
  • IPL: Lucknow Super Giants to meet Royal Challengers Bangalore in the first Eliminator today. Winners to take on Rajasthan Royals for a place in the finals
  • IPL: Sensational David Miller blasts three sixes off the first three deliveries of the last over to help Gujarat Titans beat Rajasthan Royals by 7 wickets and enter their maiden IPL final in their debut year
  • While joining US-led IPEF, PM Modi says it will bring "peace and prosperity in the Indo-Pacific region"
  • Mamata Banerjee says Bengal government will not lower VAT as the excise cut by the Centre will already reduce state's revenue by Rs 641 cr
  • Mamata Banerjee says Central agencies must be made autonomous to save democracy
  • While commuting the death sentence of 2 men and 1 woman, the Supreme Court says convict's conduct before and after crime is vital for death penalty
  • Health minister Mansukh Mandaviya slams the Covid death report of WHO at the 75th session of World Health Assembly in Geneva
US President Joe Biden says India-US ties to be among "closest on earth" //////// China and Russia send bombers near Japan even as Quad leaders were holding meetings there /////// Gujarat Titans enter IPL finals in style, beat Rajasthan Royals by 7 wickets
oppn parties
Franco Mulakkal Rape Verdict: Shocking

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2022-01-15 07:04:15

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.

A sessions court in Kerala has acquitted former bishop of Jalandahar diocese of the Roman Catholic church, Franco Mulakkal, of the charges of raping a nun repeatedly. The court just gave a one-line order setting the accused free. Since the order was unexpected given the proceedings witnessed in the court and the judge chose not to explain how he arrived at the verdict, it was severely criticized by many and termed "shocking" by Save Our Sisters (SOS), an organization that is fighting on behalf of the nuns.

It is extremely distressing that the judge chose to deliver a one-line verdict in such a high profile case. The former bishop was accused of raping a nun 13 times in three years. There were many witnesses that were examined and the matter was investigated by Additional IG of Kerala Police S Harishankar who was then the police chief of Kottayam, where the alleged crime was committed in a convent. Mulakkal was charged under IPC sections 342 (wrongful confinement), 376(2)(k) (persistent sexual assault), 376(2)(n) (repeated rape of a woman), 377 (unnatural sex) and 506(1) (criminal intimidation).

There are several facts that are relevant in this case. First, it was not a one-off crime and was repeated multiple times over a period of three years. Second, the victim, being a nun, had not immediately gone to the police and had tried to get redressal through the internal mechanism of the Church. But her complaints to church authorities had not been looked into and she was forced to lodge an FIR in 2018. All this must be on record. Third, the offender was in a position of trust and given his position, capable of suppressing the internal case against him and later influencing and browbeating witnesses and/or destroying evidence.

Finally, in any case, it has been repeatedly stressed by the Supreme Court that the testimony of the victim, if found "trustworthy, unblemished, credible" and "of sterling quality" is enough to convict the accused, without the necessity of any corroborative evidence. It remains to be seen whether the Kerala judge explains how he did not find the victim's testimony fit enough to convict the accused. The prosecution and SOS have both said that they would appeal against the order. Hence, it is hoped that justice will prevail. 

PS: Later on Friday, a 289-page judgment was delivered which said that the vicitm's testimony could not be relied upon as it was full of deviations, exaggerations and embellishments.

Read the full judgment at livelaw.in